Committee of the Islands

Keeping Sanibel Special Since 1975

Citizens Urged to Speak Out on Preserving Sanibel's Beaches

View Article Archives

March 23, 2012

Citizens Urged to Speak Out on Preserving Sanibel’s Beaches By Barbara Joy Cooley , president , Committee of the Islands Published in the Island Sun and Island Reporter on Friday , March 23 , 2012 An important meeting is scheduled for Tuesday , March 27 , regarding Sanibel’s beaches . All who care y : about the health of our beaches are urged to attend and speak out . Here’s wh About seven years ago , the city council and planning commission decided that the city should do a study of beach carrying capacity . They inserted a requirement to do this study in the Sanibel Plan , explaining that , “ The maintenance of a natural beach as a vital natural resource is important to the community’s quality of life and the economy of the City . For a variety of environmental , social , economic and historic reasons , it is important that the carrying capacity of the beach for wildlife is not diminished . ” The basis for that rationale hasn’t changed , but the city council has changed . The current council is now questioning this requirement in the plan ; however , Mayor Kevin Ruane says he wants to hear from the public on this subject before the council decides whether to nix the beach carrying capacity study from the Sanibel Plan . The first public discussion about this will be at the Planning Commission meeting on Tuesday , March 27 , at 9AM at the Sanibel City Hall , 800 Dunlop Road . Those who care about Sanibel’s beaches are encouraged to attend . The carrying capacity of the beaches was identified as a “ major issue ” the last time the Sanibel Plan was reviewed , in 2004 ? 2005 . This periodic review of the plan , called the “ Evaluation and Appraisal Report , ” or EAR , is about to begin again at the March 27 meeting . Causeway Crossings Highest Since 2004 The Sanibel Plan states that “ The carrying capacity and environmental quality of the island’s natural d on ? island physical growth and visitation coastal areas cannot be sustained if both off ? island an pressures are not addressed . ” If that was true in 2004 ? 2005 , isn’t it still true today ? Especially with signs that the economy is starting to recover ? Is there any real evidence that there are fewer people on the beaches today ? Is there any reason to believe that the number of people using Sanibel’s beaches will decline in the future ? In fact , the number of vehicles crossing the causeway in 2011 rose by 70,000 , to a total of 2,950,000 , the highest figure since 2004 . And January 2012 crossings were up 4.8 % from 2011 . How do we set reasonable limitations on the use of Sanibel’s beaches without the data to support those decisions ? The Sanibel Plan asserts that “ To preserve the natural condition of Sanibel beaches , there is a need to determine acceptable limits of change , if any , to the Gulf Beach Zone . . . . There remains a need to develop a scientific methodology to establish baseline conditions , to monitor the change of conditions over time and to assess the extent to which these changes can be attributed to human activities . ” Although the requirement to do this study has been in the Sanibel Plan for seven or so years , it has not yet been done . Is it time to do the study ? Or is it time to dismiss the importance of our beaches by eliminating this requirement from the Plan ? The first opportunity for Sanibel citizens to voice their concerns about this issue will be on March 27 at ng commission meeting . The Mayor has asked for our input ; let''s show up . . . . and speak out . the planni The Committee of the Islands welcomes your input on this subject . Email your comments to u can coti @ coti.org . You can find commentaries on other island issues on our web site at coti.org , and yo visit Committee of the Islands on Facebook .

Download document

Click here to download article.